EHS Today
  • Magazine Subscription
  • ENewsletters
  • EHS Education
  • Safety Leadership Conference
  • America's Safest Companies
    • Search
  • EHS Today Intelligence
  • Safety
  • Health
  • Environment
  • Standards
  • Safety Technology
  • Training & Engagement
  • Leadership
  • Topics
    EHS IntelligenceEnvironmentHealthSafetyLeadershipStandardsConstructionPPESafety TechnologyTraining & EngagementEmergency ManagementCOVID-19 CrisisIndustrial Hygiene
    Resources
    Member BenefitsSafety Leadership ConferenceEHS EducationAmerica's Safest Companies AwardsWebinarsWhite PapersWorkplace Safety AcademyMagazine SubscriptioneNewsletter SubscriptionLatest HeadlinesContact UsAdvertisePress ReleasesPrivacy & Cookie PolicyTerms of Service
    https://www.facebook.com/pages/EHS-Today/66542218626?ref=ts
    https://www.linkedin.com/groups/4355311
    https://twitter.com/EHSToday
    1. Archive

    Opponents Charge Ergo Rule Unreasonable

    March 6, 2000
    In its formal comments submitted to OSHA, the National Coalition on Ergonomics charges that the proposed ergonomics standard is 'unreasonable' and 'unworkable.'
    EHS Today Staff

    OSHA's proposed ergonomics regulation reaches conclusions that no reasonable person would find, charged the National Coalition on Ergonomics (NCE) in formal comments submitted to the agency.

    "OSHA's fix for ergonomics is beyond comprehension," said Ed Gilroy, co-chair of NCE, which represents employers from every sector of American business.

    In reference to the coalition's comments, Gilroy added, "Looking at the data and the record as a whole, there is no way any reasonable person could agree with OSHA's contention that there is scientific, legal or public policy justification for the agency's proposed ergonomics rule."

    The NCE's formal comments blasted OSHA's ergonomics proposal saying, "its requirements are subjective and ambiguous, assuring that an employer could never achieve compliance because, in all of its more than 1,000 pages, not a single proven solution is provided."

    The coalition has long supported safety and health programs, but in OSHA's proposed ergonomics regulation, the NCE only sees a costly experiment that fails to assure the prevention of injuries.

    "Nothing is the proposed regulation assures prevention of even one injury," said Gilroy. "The only assurance is that it is the most expensive regulation ever proposed by OSHA. Even the agency admits its estimates are the highest costs ever proposed and we think those estimates are unrealistically low."

    According to OSHA, the cost of the regulation is estimated to be $4.2 billion.

    The NCE pointed out that a review of OSHA's economic analysis by the National Economic Research Associates found, "OSHA has understated control costs, overstated productivity gains, and overstated the effectiveness of job control interventions."

    Additionally, Food Distributors International, a trade organization representing grocery distribution centers, estimates the cost of the regulation to its industry alone at $26 billion the first year with recurring annual costs of $6 billion.

    In its written comments, the NCE also charged that OSHA is using this rulemaking process as an unlawful subterfuge to avoid responsibility of proving that work is the direct and sole cause of these conditions and that there are workplace solutions to prevent them.

    "OSHA has decreed -- without scientific foundation -- that all of these ailments are work-related unless the employer can prove otherwise," said Gilroy. "The result is a regulatory monstrosity that would hurt businesses without the certainty of helping employees."

    The NCE's formal comments will be placed on the group's Web site at www.ncergo.org

    Continue Reading

    Workplace Flexibility Associated with Lower Risk of Cardiovascular Disease

    Making ‘Cents’ of Workplace Safety Programs

    Sponsored Recommendations

    Is Your Safety Program Effective? 10 Questions Every Safety Leader Should Ask

    Nov. 7, 2023

    Purposeful Presence: How Leaders Show Up to Amp Up Performance

    Nov. 7, 2023

    The Truth and Challenges of Cultivating Chronic Unease

    Nov. 7, 2023

    Autopsy of an Injury Uncovering 18 Million Exposures in One Activity

    Nov. 7, 2023

    Voice your opinion!

    To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of EHS Today, create an account today!

    I already have an account

    New

    EEOC Proposes Sweeping Employer Guidance

    COP28 Reservations, More Marijuana Headaches and Productivity Hacks: What We’re Reading This Week

    Making Naloxone Part of Emergency Preparedness Plan

    Most Read

    Are Carbon Offsets Effective or Just Corporate Greenwashing?

    Written Safety Plans: Not Just a Paperwork Exercise

    EHS and LMS Platforms – A Match Made in Safety


    Sponsored

    Safety maturity curve - A journey from lagging indicators to leading indicators

    Unlocking EHS performance through system consolidation mega trend

    Everything you need to know about EHS Incident Reporting

    EHS Today
    https://www.facebook.com/pages/EHS-Today/66542218626?ref=ts
    https://www.linkedin.com/groups/4355311
    https://twitter.com/EHSToday
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Advertise
    • Do Not Sell or Share
    • Privacy & Cookie Policy
    • Terms of Service
    © 2023 Endeavor Business Media, LLC. All rights reserved.
    Endeavor Business Media Logo