Survey Finds OSHA Access to Audits Harmful

April 26, 1999
It's little surprise that 18- to 34-year-olds are at the heart of a nationwide increase in illegal drug use, and the manufacturing industry traditionally draws heavily from this pool of job seekers.

The Occuational Safety and Health Administration's (OSHA) unlimited access to occupational safety and health audits results in many companies issuing vague reports and limiting their circulation, according to a survey by Organization Resources Counselors Inc. (ORC).

In March, ORC surveyed 150 large member firms to assess the impact of OSHA's enforcement policy which allows compliance officers to demand company voluntary audits. Forty-one companies responded.

ORC said for audits to work as intended, the results must be "blunt and critical," widely circulated and discussed with all affected individuals, and retained and available until the findings are fully resolved.

While all the companies performed safety and health audits, over half said OSHA's policy had an impact on their company's audit practices. Said one firm: "Clearly the threat of OSHA being able to use in-house audit results against the company creates an undesirable pressure to not document serious negative findings, which in turn negatively impacts our ability to rectify the conditions."

ORC also found that half the companies perform their audits under legal privilege and nine out of 10 place limitations on the circulation and retention of the audit results. However, only 12 percent of the companies reported that an OSHA inspector or federal or state official had ever requested to see their audit results.

ORC supports restrictions on OSHA access to audits, and testified in support of the Self Audit Promotion Act of 1999, H.R. 1438, a bill by Rep. Cass Ballenger, R-N.C., which would prohibit using audit results as the basis for an OSHA citation. With this bill, said ORC: "Employers and employees could freely discuss the audit and abatement plans. Audit documents would no longer need to be destroyed but would be available for reference purposes. Safety and health professionals, not attorneys, could be responsible for conducting the audit."

Sponsored Recommendations

June 16, 2025
This free guide will define complacency, explain individual and organizational complacency, provide insights into the contributing factors and give a high-level overview of what...
May 22, 2025
Heat stress is a serious challenge that poses immediate and long-term health effects for workers in high-temperature environments. To combat heat stress, it's critical to educate...
May 15, 2025
Foot safety is a serious concern. At your next safety meeting, give your crew eye-opening facts about feet and how proper footwear matters more than they may know. Show your team...
May 15, 2025
If reimbursing employees for safety footwear is how its always been done, maybe its time to learn about the advantages a managed footwear program can offer instead. See a ...

Voice your opinion!

To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of EHS Today, create an account today!