OSHA Fines Florida Contractors Following Fatal Accident

OSHA cited Brooksville Crane Services Inc. and Chuck Evans Inc.\r\nfor safety violations and proposed penalties\r\ntotaling $110,250 following a fatal accident at a residential construction site.

OSHA cited Brooksville Crane Services Inc. and Chuck Evans Inc. for willful and serious safety violations and proposed penalties totaling $110,250 after investigating a fatal accident at a residential construction site in Port Richey, Fla.

A worker, employed by framing contractor Chuck Evans Inc., was killed on Oct. 9, when a beam being lifted by a crane shifted and struck him in the head.

Following an investigation of the accident, OSHA cited both Chuck Evans Inc. and Brooksville Crane Service Inc., the owner/operator of the crane used to lift and place structural parts during construction of the private residences.

Brooksville Crane Service received one willful citation with a $70,000 penalty for making structural changes to the crane without checking manufacturer''s specifications or limitations or consulting a qualified engineer.

"This company created the hazard responsible for the accident through its indifference to worker safety," Lawrence Falck, OSHA''s Tampa area director. "Despite full knowledge of requirements to follow manufacturer''s specifications, this employer increased the radius and weight capacity of the crane beyond the maximum recommended for safe handling."

Falck continued, "As a result of overloading the crane, its hydraulic system failed which allowed the load to shift and strike an employee. Had the company followed the manufacturer''s specifications or contacted a qualified engineer to determine potential consequences, this accident could have been avoided."

Nine serious citations against Brooksville Crane resulted in additional penalties of $35,350. The serious violations included:

  • the crane''s synthetic nylon slings showed numerous signs of serious wear and were not properly marked to identify manufacturer, rated capacity or type of material;
  • crane parts were in disrepair;
  • neither a load chart nor hand signal chart was posted in the crane''s cab or available on the jobsite, and;
  • alterations made by the employer to the crane did not have written manufacturer''s approval prior to use.

Falck said, "Just as Brooksville Crane''s action created a hazardous situation, Chuck Evans'' failure to act placed employees in harm''s way."

The company was cited for two serious violations with a penalty of $4,900 for failing to provide protective helmets to workers in areas with overhead hazards and not removing the crane''s synthetic web slings from service when they showed signs of excessive cuts and abrasions that the red safety warning strand was visible.

Each of the cited companies has 15 working days to contest OSHA citations and proposed penalties before the independent Occupational Safety and Health Review Board.

by Virginia Sutcliffe

Hide comments


  • Allowed HTML tags: <em> <strong> <blockquote> <br> <p>

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.