Skip navigation
Balancing the Pros and Cons of Machine Guarding Technologies

Balancing the Pros and Cons of Machine Guarding Technologies

Despite having been introduced in the 1950s, safety mats remain an effective tool in machine guarding programs.

The down home American adage, "If it ain't broke, don't fix it," seems like it must date back to colonial times. In fact, the phrase was popularized in the 1970s, but its widespread use makes it seem older than it really is. In that sense, the phrase is a bit like safety mats.

Introduced in the 1950s, safety mats became such a common tool in industrial machine guarding that some people believe they date back to the Industrial Revolution. Not quite.

Despite the introduction of newer technologies such as safety laser scanners, safety mats remain relevant and both machine guarding technologies have their place in today's industrial landscape. Decision-makers need a good understanding of the basic function of each type of technology to make informed decisions regarding the type of guarding to employ for safety.

How  They  Work

Safety mats are easy to understand. Typically, a safety mat is a simple, normally open switch that closes when weight is applied to it. Each safety mat has four wires that, when wired to a controller, provide the redundancy required to monitor the wires for opens and shorts due to wiring issues or possible damage. Good safety mats feature heavy-duty, impact-resistant construction, with molded traction patterns to help prevent employees from slipping.

Safety laser scanners use time-of-flight technology for distance detection. A pulsed laser beam emitted from the scanner is reflected back if it meets an object within the predefined areas. The reflected signal is registered by the scanner's receiver, which uses the time between sending and receiving the signal to calculate the distance between the scanner and the object.

Stationary  versus  Mobile

Safety mats widely are used in stationary applications, while safety laser scanners may be used in stationary or mobile applications. Safety mat devices are used to guard the area around hazardous machines. They are available in variety of sizes and custom shapes to suitably fit many floor layouts, especially around awkwardly shaped machines where other guarding devices are not flexible or practical to use.

When safety mats are secured to the floor by proper trims, they provide effective sensing across their entire surface to send a stop signal to the machine before the hazard can be reached by an individual. Typical applications for safety mats include:

  • Welding robots
  • Assembly machinery
  • Material handling equipment
  • Packaging machinery
  • Punches
  • Presses
  • Robot work cells
Safety Laser scanners may be used in stationary or mobile applications.

In addition to the stationary applications listed above,  safety laser scanners often are used in vehicle navigation and collision avoidance applications. Mobile applications require much greater flexibility than stationary ones. Safety laser scanners provide this through a feature known as zone set switching. Factors used to establish zones include safety standards, physics, resolution, environment, traffic and maximum range. A safety zone must be able to detect low reflective objects as small as 70 millimeters within the scanner's maximum safety zone.

Many zone sets can be programmed into a safety laser scanner, which then can be switched from one set to another based on specific needs for a process or operation. For example, the scanner can be looking at "zone A" for first part of the operation, "zone B" for the second part, "zone C" for the third part and so on. This ability to dynamically change is key for mobile applications. With a safety laser scanner users can program different patterns and switch from one to another based on the immediate need.

In a moving application such as on an automated guided vehicle (AGV), safety laser scanners enable faster and more precise navigation through the factory floor for maximum efficiency.

Environmental Factors

Safety mats are robust and able to work in virtually any environment; safety laser scanners are more subject to environmental issues. Laser scanners are optical devices; they have a sensitive receiving element that requires the control of certain conditions, such as dust or smoke in the environment and ambient light. This doesn't mean that scanners can't be used in such environments, but users have to take certain precautions. The laser scanners need to be mounted out of direct sunlight and in locations where there isn't excessive smoke or dust. For example, if there is a skylight in the ceiling of the work area, a scanner cannot be positioned to look up directly into the skylight because it could be "blinded" by direct light at high noon.

Consider a scenario from the automotive industry: A tier one supplier to a major automaker presses and cuts fabrics for car interiors. During the manufacturing process, a lot of lint and fiber is generated. Personnel on the plant floor are compensated in part on a per-piece basis, so operators literally run up and down a heat press as they aim to make as many parts as possible. As they move, they stir up dust and fiber, causing the laser safety scanners to see fibers flying for 10- to 20-second increments. So instead of producing more parts, fewer are being manufactured because scanners shut down the press until the fibers settle.

In this application and others like it, safety mats could be a viable and reliable alternative to safety laser scanners.

Lifecycle Concerns and Costs

Safety mats largely are impervious to outside factors affecting their performance. However, if they are used in an environment where forklifts are repeatedly driven over them, this traffic may reduce their effective life. Additionally, exposure to organic or chlorinated solvents also may compromise their integrity and performance.

For safety scanners, shock and vibration probably are the major threats to their performance. Also, some fluids or lubricants may penetrate their seals. Physical impact also is a risk, so it is recommended that scanners are mounted away from operators or other floor traffic.

A pulsed laser beam emitted from the safety laser scanner is reflected back if it meets an object within the predefined areas.

Historically,  safety mats were about a quarter of the cost of safety laser scanners; but that cost differential has closed by half over the last decade. Today, cost of ownership factors tend to favor scanners in large-area applications, while in small-area applications, safety mats tend to be more cost-effective. Installation takes longer with safety mats because they physically are anchored to the plant floor, but installation and troubleshooting for safety mats considerably are simpler than with safety laser scanners. For OEMs shipping machines that require guarding, it is easier to ship with laser scanners mounted than to ship with safety mats that need to be installed at the customer site.

Another issue is the manufacturing process and site configuration. Many factories have flexible work cells that can be picked up and rearranged, so they easily are reconfigured as processes are adjusted or refined. If those cells have safety mats, they need to be uninstalled and reinstalled at the new cell location – a time-consuming and laborious process. So for any installation where equipment periodically is moved, safety mats likely are not recommended.

Final Considerations

Most OEMs will look to vendors who supply to receive an objective consultation. In the end, both safety mats and safety laser scanners are viable options for manufacturers. While laser safety scanners are more sophisticated and flexible and applicable in both stationary and mobile applications, they can't be used confidently in some environments due to their sensitivity to light, dust and other process factors.

In these situations, safety mats continue to function well and remain a complement to safety laser scanner technology. Each has its merits. Their application should depend on how those merits meet the objective conditions of the manufacturing environment in which they are applied.

Sergio Aguilar is a product manager and Trang Nguyen is a product specialist at Omron Automation and Safety, Fremont, Calif.

Hide comments


  • Allowed HTML tags: <em> <strong> <blockquote> <br> <p>

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.