Jury to Decide Fate of Dairy Owner

Sept. 21, 2004
The fate of Patrick Faria, the operations manager and co-owner of Aguiar-Faria & Sons Dairy in Gustine, Calif., rests in the hands of a jury, who must decide if he was criminally liable for the deaths of two workers who drowned in dairy waste on Feb. 22, 2001.

Faria was charged with involuntary manslaughter in the deaths of Enrique Araiza and Jose Alatorre, who drowned after climbing into a 30-foot-deep pipe in a manure pit.

Prosecutor Gale Filter claimed the men did not receive proper training on the hazards of confined spaces and were not wearing appropriate personal protective equipment, such as respirators.

"There is no way you are going to go into a dairy pit if you have knowledge of what those dangers are," Filter said.

The defense countered that although the state knew about the hazards associated with manure pits as far back as 1990, Cal-OSHA did not cite Aguiar-Faria & Sons Dairy for confined space violations until the men drowned in 2001.

Defense attorney Kirk McAllister pointed out that when the Gustine Fire Department responded to the call about the men, they did not have the necessary equipment or training to retrieve the men and had to request help from the Merced Fire Department. He added that the firefighter who climbed into the shaft to retrieve the bodies had never made a confined-space rescue.

One witness testified that he climbed into the same shaft 2 years before the fatal incident to make a repair and was not wearing a respirator.

"That is the man who was trained by a company doing service for dairies," McAllister told the Modesto Bee, noting that if he wasn't wearing proper protective equipment, that Faria should not be expected to know that his employees should receive special training and wear PPE to do so.

Filter disagreed, saying the deaths were the result of "indifference, apathy and greed" on the part of Faria.

The jury is expected to reach a decision this week.

About the Author

Sandy Smith

Sandy Smith is the former content director of EHS Today, and is currently the EHSQ content & community lead at Intelex Technologies Inc. She has written about occupational safety and health and environmental issues since 1990.

Sponsored Recommendations

Committing to Safety: Why Leadership’s Role in Safety Excellence is Key

Jan. 13, 2025
Leadership has the power to transform an organization through their behavior and vision, which can result in the creation of an organizational culturethat supports safety excellence...

Speak Up! Cementing "See Something, Say Something" to Drive Safety

Jan. 13, 2025
Many organizations promote "see something, say something" to encourage their people to intervene and make work safe. But most don't go far enough to equip teams with the skills...

The Truth and Challenges of Cultivating Chronic Unease

Jan. 13, 2025
DEKRA announces its latest white paper, “The Truth and Challenges of Cultivating Chronic Unease,” as a definitive look into why being vulnerable to incidents strengthens our commitment...

Mitigating Risks: Strategies for Safeguarding Workers in Hazardous Workplaces

Jan. 13, 2025
Join our expert team in taking on the challenge to make safety part of your organization’s DNA as work, the workforce, and workplaces evolve.

Voice your opinion!

To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of EHS Today, create an account today!